Skip to main content

Thursday night in Houston is a matchup of two teams sitting well outside the playoff race, the Colts at 3-7 and the Texans at 3-6, but don’t let the records fool you. This game has real fantasy stakes. The injury report has rearranged both offenses: Houston is without Marvin Harrison Jr. and Woody Marks, and Indianapolis is starting a makeshift offensive line in front of a receiver room the trade deadline stripped bare. Here’s how the absences reshape each lineup decision.

The Injury Report That Shapes Everything

Texans out: RB Woody Marks (concussion), WR Marvin Harrison Jr. (hamstring, second straight game), TE Brevin Jordan (foot/illness) and DE Danielle Hunter (hamstring, second straight game). RB David Montgomery is back after missing every game since Week 5 with a groin injury, and Tank Dell is not on the report.

Colts out: LT Bernhard Raimann (concussion), RT Jalen Travis (knee), CB Charvarius Ward (knee), DT Jerry Tillery (calf) and TE Will Mallory (hamstring). CB Sauce Gardner (calf) and WR Anthony Gould (toe) are questionable. Alec Pierce remains on injured reserve, and the Colts dealt Josh Downs to Kansas City and Keenan Allen to San Francisco at the Nov. 10 deadline.

Put that together and the shape of the game is clear: Houston’s passing attack faces a secondary that could be without both Ward and Gardner, while Daniel Jones drops back behind two backup tackles.

Houston Texans: Who to Start

C.J. Stroud, QB: Start with confidence

Stroud is playing the best football of his career. He’s at 2,462 yards with 19 touchdowns and only three interceptions, and he has thrown multiple touchdowns in four straight games, including a five-touchdown, 384-yard explosion against the Chargers in Week 9 and three more in last week’s 27-24 loss in Cleveland. The one red flag is that his season low came against this same Colts team in Week 3, 167 yards in a 19-17 loss. That was a different Indianapolis defense, though. The Colts have since traded away DeForest Buckner, are missing Ward and may be missing Gardner. Stroud is a top-10 quarterback play this week.

Nico Collins, WR: Locked-in WR1

With Harrison sidelined, Collins is the focal point and the volume proves it. He drew 16 targets in Cleveland and turned them into nine catches for 94 yards and a touchdown. He’s at 37 catches, 478 yards and five scores on the season. Against a depleted Colts secondary, he’s a WR1 with double-digit target upside.

Tank Dell and Xavier Hutchinson, WR: Flex considerations

Harrison’s absence opens a second-receiver role, and two players will share it. Hutchinson has been the steadier option and found the end zone last week. Dell is the bigger-play threat but has been a small part of the offense this season. In a game where Stroud should throw efficiently, Hutchinson is a viable flex in 12-team leagues and Dell is a deeper-league dart throw. Neither is a must-start.

Dalton Schultz, TE: Low-end TE1

Schultz isn’t flashy, but he’s caught 36 of his 49 targets for 375 yards and gets a small boost with Jordan out. In a thin tight end landscape, a reliable short-area target in a Stroud offense that is clicking is good enough to start.

David Montgomery, RB: RB2 on volume, with caution

Marks had handled the backfield for the past four weeks, and his concussion hands the job back to Montgomery, who practiced fully all week. Emari Demercado is the expected No. 2. The opportunity is there: the Colts’ run defense has been leaky all season. The concern is efficiency. Montgomery was not productive running behind this line in September, and he’s coming off six weeks on the shelf with a soft-tissue injury, so Houston could limit his snaps early. Treat him as a volume-based RB2 whose value depends on goal-line work. Demercado is only a deep-league handcuff.

Indianapolis Colts: Proceed Carefully

Jonathan Taylor, RB: Still a start, but the ceiling has shrunk

Taylor has 739 yards and eight touchdowns on 177 carries, but none of those touchdowns have come in the last three weeks, and the backfield is no longer his alone. Rookie Seth McGowan posted career highs last week with 12 carries for 77 yards and a 4-yard touchdown, while Taylor had 16 carries for 83 yards. That’s close to an even split. Add a beat-up offensive line and a likely negative game script, and Taylor’s path to a big game depends on breaking a long run or catching passes out of the backfield. He’s still an RB2 in every format given his talent and passing-down role, but lower your expectations from his early-season RB1 level.

Seth McGowan, RB: The waiver-wire name to know

McGowan’s role has grown in each of the last two games, and he’s been the more efficient runner. He’s an RB4 tonight, a desperation flex only, but he’s an important handcuff to roster in leagues where Taylor managers need insurance, and a stash in deeper formats if the Colts keep shifting carries to their rookie.

Daniel Jones, QB: Sit

Jones has 1,830 yards, seven touchdowns and 12 interceptions this season, and last week against Miami he went 11-of-22 for 108 yards with two picks. Now he faces Will Anderson Jr. and Houston’s pass rush without Raimann or Travis protecting the edges. Even in superflex leagues, he’s a lineup filler, not a start.

Tyler Warren, TE: Volume floor only

Warren leads the Colts with 40 catches, but those have produced just 276 yards. With Downs and Allen gone and Mallory out, he’s the most reliable pass-catcher left on the roster, which keeps him in the low-end TE1 conversation on targets alone. The catch is that a pressured Jones has turned short targets into empty production. Start him if your alternatives are streamers. Don’t expect much yardage.

Colts receivers: Avoid

The Colts’ wide receiver group is now Ashton Dulin, Laquon Treadwell, Deion Burks, Nick Westbrook-Ikhine and, if healthy, Anthony Gould. No one in that group has earned a dependable target share, and last week no Colts receiver topped 30 yards. None belong in season-long lineups.

Defense and Kickers

The Texans D/ST is a top streaming option this week. Jones has turned the ball over repeatedly, Houston’s pass rush gets to face two backup tackles, even with Hunter out. If the Texans’ D/ST is on your waiver wire, add it and start it. Ka’imi Fairbairn is a solid kicker play attached to the stronger offense in the game. Leave the Colts’ defense on the bench against a quarterback this hot.

Start/Sit Summary

  • Start: C.J. Stroud, Nico Collins, Jonathan Taylor (as an RB2), Dalton Schultz, Texans D/ST
  • Flex/borderline: David Montgomery, Xavier Hutchinson, Tyler Warren
  • Bench: Daniel Jones, Tank Dell (outside deep leagues), Seth McGowan (roster, don’t start), all Colts wide receivers

The bottom line: this is a game to lean on Houston’s passing game. Stroud and Collins are the anchors, the Harrison absence gives Hutchinson a real role, and the Colts’ combination of a depleted secondary and a makeshift offensive line points the same direction. On the Indianapolis side, the most important development isn’t anything that happens tonight. It’s whether McGowan’s share keeps growing, because that changes Taylor’s value for the rest of the season.