Skip to main content

About 22 to 24 games into the NHL season, most fantasy hockey managers have stopped asking whether a hot or cold start is real and started acting on it. Before you do, look at one number: shooting percentage. Over 20 games it swings far more than shot volume, ice time or power-play role, and it pulls back toward a player’s normal level faster than almost anything else in the box score. This is the regression check. All numbers are through Wednesday’s games and match on NHL.com and ESPN.

Sell high: the shooting percentage won’t last

Kirill Kaprizov, LW, Minnesota Wild

Kaprizov has 18 goals and 43 points in 24 games, third in the league in scoring behind Connor McDavid and Leon Draisaitl. He has also scored on 24.3 percent of his 74 shots. For three straight seasons he shot 16.6, 17.2 and 16.7 percent, about as steady as an elite finisher gets. The volume isn’t there either: 74 shots in 24 games is about three a night. His 25 assists and 21:22 a night on the top line mean the points won’t dry up, but a 60-goal pace won’t hold. If someone in your league will pay a first-round price for him as a top-three fantasy forward, listen. If not, keep him and expect fewer goals from here.

Evan Bouchard, D, Edmonton Oilers

This is the biggest outlier on the board. Bouchard has 12 goals in 24 games on 63 shots, a 19.0 percent rate for a defenseman whose last three seasons came in at 8.2, 6.0 and 9.5 percent. His career high is 21 goals, set across all 82 games last season. The 25 assists, 14 power-play points and 25:18 of ice time are real, and he stays a top-five fantasy defenseman. But the goals will slow down sharply. Managers in leagues that weight goals heavily should see what he can bring back in a trade.

Beckett Sennecke, RW, Anaheim Ducks

Sennecke has 26 points in 22 games, but his 12 goals came on just 53 shots, 22.6 percent. As a rookie last season he scored 23 goals on an 11.7 percent rate. The good news is the role: he is playing 20:16 a night and has 11 power-play points. Hold him in deeper leagues, but in standard formats he is the easiest Duck to trade for a proven name while his numbers look this good.

Sebastian Aho, C, Carolina Hurricanes

Aho is shooting 20.3 percent (12 goals on 59 shots) after rates of 14.0 and 13.8 the last two seasons. Shorthanded points and a steady role keep his floor high, but at under three shots a game he is closer to a 30-goal player than the 45-goal pace he is on now.

The hot shooter who is mostly real: Cutter Gauthier

Gauthier is tied with Draisaitl for the league lead with 21 goals, and he has done it in 22 games and is shooting 21.4 percent, up from 14.4 percent during last season’s 41-goal breakout. Some of that will come back down. Unlike the names above, though, the volume backs him up: 98 shots, second in the NHL behind Kyle Connor’s 99, or about 4.5 a game. Eleven of his goals have come on the power play. Even if his shooting percentage drops back to last year’s level, that many shots still produce a 40-plus goal season. Don’t sell him for less than elite value.

Connor fits the same profile. He is shooting 18.2 percent on a league-high 99 shots, so even with some regression the volume makes him a hold.

Buy low: the goals are coming

Mitch Marner, RW, Vegas Golden Knights

Marner has 26 points in 22 games, and 23 of them are assists. He has scored three times on 54 shots, a 5.6 percent rate from a player who shot 16.5, 15.6 and 14.5 percent the last three seasons. He is actually shooting a little more often than usual, and he has 12 power-play points. Managers who only see three goals may sell him cheap. Even at a normal rate he would have about eight goals by now. Go get him.

Macklin Celebrini, C, San Jose Sharks

Celebrini’s start looks merely good next to last season’s 45-goal, 115-point year: nine goals and 27 points in 22 games. The shot volume is up. He has 93 shots, fourth in the league, and is playing 23:07 a night. His shooting percentage has dropped to 9.7 from 15.7 last season. Shooting this often with that much ice time, he will get his goals. If the manager who has him is disappointed, use that.

Clayton Keller, RW, Utah Mammoth

Keller has 29 points, including 24 assists and 18 power-play points, but only five goals on 60 shots (8.3 percent). His last three seasons came in at 14.5, 13.8 and 11.6. The 11.6 from last season suggests a slight decline, so don’t expect a 30-goal pace. But the playmaking is elite, and a few more goals would make him a top-25 fantasy forward again.

Alex DeBrincat, RW, Detroit Red Wings

DeBrincat scored 39 and 41 goals the last two seasons on 16.0 and 14.3 percent shooting. This year he has seven goals on 77 shots, or 9.1 percent, with 16 points in 22 games. He is putting 3.5 shots a night on goal and playing 19:40. He is the cheapest of these targets to acquire, so make an offer now.

Timo Meier, RW, New Jersey Devils

Meier has only 11 points in 22 games, but he has 83 shots, tied for eighth in the league, and has scored on just 6.0 percent of them. That is low even after last season’s 8.9 percent. The bigger concern is 16:41 of ice time with only three power-play points. In standard points leagues he is a stash, not a must-add. In formats that count shots, hits and penalty minutes, he is already returning value and should be a buy.

Defensemen: Roman Josi

Josi has 23 points in 22 games, all but two of them assists, and zero power-play goals despite 11 power-play assists. He is shooting 3.3 percent on 61 shots after 8.6, 6.0 and 7.2 percent the last three seasons. He is playing 25:34 a night. At his usual rate he would have two or three more goals by now, and they will come, and he is a strong second defenseman to target in categories leagues.

The quick list

  • Sell high: Kaprizov (24.3 percent), Bouchard (19.0), Sennecke (22.6), Aho (20.3)
  • Mostly real, hold: Gauthier (98 shots), Connor (99 shots)
  • Buy low: Marner (5.6), Celebrini (9.7), Keller (8.3), DeBrincat (9.1), Josi (3.3)
  • Deep-league or category stash: Meier (6.0 percent on 83 shots)

Shooting percentage doesn’t tell you everything. Linemates, power-play units and injuries all move the numbers. But it is the stat most likely to change by the end of the season, so make your trades before it does.